FREE DELIVERY on all orders over £25 Shop now in our PANTRY STORE

Guide to Cheese and Chutney

by | Nov 11, 2026 | Christmas, Chutney

A Guide to Cheese & Chutney at Christmas

Making your favourite cheeses taste even more amazing.

We’re massive cheese fans here at Northumbrian Pantry. So many of our chutneys, relishes and pickles were created with a cheeseboard in mind, and Christmas is when they really come into their own.

Over the years, so many of you have asked us, especially at fairs and events, “Which chutney goes with this cheese?” We’ve had lots of lovely chats across the stall (and done plenty of tasting along the way), so we’ve picked up a fair bit. We wouldn’t call ourselves experts, but we’d love to share what we’ve learned.

Here’s what we’ve found: a spoonful of chutney doesn’t just sit next to the cheese. It changes how the cheese tastes. Cheese is rich and salty, chutney brings sweetness, sharpness and spice, and when the two get along, every mouthful is better than either on its own. It really comes down to the job you want your chutney to do, and I reckon there are six: contrast, cleanse, echo, soothe, lift and brighten.

PANTRY STORE

1. Contrast: sweet meets salty

Big, bold cheeses need a partner who’ll stand up to them. A bit of sweetness tames the salt, and suddenly a strong cheese tastes rich and rounded rather than sharp. It’s the showstopper of the board.

Our pick: Christmas Chutney with Stilton. It’s a Victorian recipe with prunes, dates and apricots, plus ginger and allspice. The dates give it a gorgeous caramel, almost dark-chocolate richness. Pop it on a salty, creamy Stilton and, honestly, that’s Christmas sorted. We only make it from October to December, so now’s the time.

2. Cleanse: a fresh, sharp reset

We’ve all been there: third slice of brie, and everything starts to taste the same. A little sharpness from vinegar or tangy fruit cuts through the richness and wakes your palate up again. This is where pickles really earn their place.

Our pick: Pickled Spiced Pears with blue cheese. We peel every pear by hand, and they’ve won a [2-star] Great Taste award. A slice with a sharp blue is sweet, clean and fresh all at once.

3. Echo: birds of a feather

Sometimes the best match isn’t an opposite, it’s a kindred spirit. Earthy with earthy, smoky with something robust, and each one brings out the best in the other.

Our pick: Northumberland Cheese Company’s Chilli Original with our award-winning Chilli Jelly. Chilli with chilli: the jelly picks up the warmth already running through this wonderfully creamy cheese and turns it up a notch. A real kindred-spirit pairing, and a lovely surprise on a Christmas board.

Also lovely with: Spiced Beetroot & Apple Chutney with goat’s cheese. A classic for good reason. Earthy beetroot meets the cheese’s gentle tang, and the apple and spices keep it bright. It looks beautiful on the board too.

4. Soothe: gentle does it

Not every cheese wants a fight. Soft, buttery and mild cheeses get lost under anything too bold, so give them something mellow that rounds them out and lets the cheese stay the star.

Our pick: Tomato & Red Pepper Chutney with a buttery cow’s cheese. One of our lighter chutneys. The sweet red peppers snuggle up to a silky cheese, and it’s the pairing nearly everyone round the table will love, fussy eaters included.

Also lovely with: Spiced Apricot & Orange Chutney and a mild sheep’s cheese. The apricot and orange calm the tang and add a little festive warmth.

5. Lift: a little festive glow

Ginger and chilli are the party guests who get everyone chatting. A touch of warmth brings a mild or herby cheese to life. Think of it like seasoning: a little goes a long way.

Our pick: Pear & Ginger Chutney with blue cheese. Soft pear with a gentle ginger kick, lovely against a creamy blue. If you fancy something a bit quieter than Stilton and Christmas Chutney, this is your one.

Also lovely with: Chilli Relish and a smooth, herby cheese, [such as Northumberland Cheese Company’s Nettle]. Sweet heat and herbs are a very happy couple.

6. Brighten: perfect for harder, chalkier, crumbly cheeses

Harder, chalkier, crumbly cheeses like Wensleydale can be a little serious on their own. A fruity chutney adds juiciness and a bright, sunny sweetness that brings them to life. There’s a reason Wensleydale and fruit cake are such old friends in Yorkshire!

Our pick: Spiced Apricot & Orange Chutney with Wensleydale. Fresh, crumbly Wensleydale meets juicy apricot and zesty orange, with just a little warmth from the spices. Simple, and so good.

From closer to home: Northumberland Cheese Company’s [Redesdale sheep’s cheese], handmade here in Northumberland. It’s sweet and velvety with a lovely tang, and it’s brilliant with Apricot & Orange too. 

And now… the cracker question

My one rule: the bolder the chutney, the plainer the cracker. The cracker’s there to carry the good stuff, not steal the show.

  • Water biscuits: crisp and neutral, so the cheese and chutney do the talking. Best with soft cheeses and gentler chutneys.
  • Oatcakes: nutty, sturdy and properly northern. Made for cheddar, Stilton and our richer chutneys.
  • Charcoal crackers: let’s be honest, these are mostly for the photos. Pale cheese and jewel-bright chutney on a black cracker looks fab.
  • Seeded crispbreads: extra crunch and a toasty flavour that suits milder cheeses.
  • Fruit and nut crackers: delicious, but go easy. With a fruity chutney the sweetness can double up, so pair them with something sharp, like our Spiced Pears or Piccalilli.

There’s so much choice these days, so ask at your local deli or farm shop. They’ll know what suits their cheeses, and lots of them stock our jars too.

Putting your board together

Pick three to five cheeses with different textures and give each one its own jar. The fun comes from the mix. Every pairing below does a different job: some jars contrast with their cheese, some cleanse the palate, some echo the flavours, some soothe, some brighten and some lift. Put a few different jobs on the same board and every mouthful is a little different. It goes from bold to gentle and back again.

These aren’t hard and fast rules, just a starting point. Mix it up, try your own pairings and see what you like best.

Contrast: the jar is the opposite of the cheese, like sweet and fruity against salty and sharp.
Cleanse: something tangy to cut through rich cheese and get you ready for the next bite.
Echo: the jar picks up a flavour that’s already in the cheese, like smoky with smoky or earthy with earthy.
Soothe: gentle, rounded flavours that sit comfortably next to milder cheeses.
Brighten: a fresh, zingy jar that freshens up a heavier or more savoury cheese.
Lift: a bit of warmth or a kick of heat to wake a cheese up.

Let us do the pairing for you. Our Christmas cheeseboard gift packs make a lovely present, or a very good excuse to treat yourself.

The Christmas Cheeseboard Gift Pack comes in our Nutcracker tower and has four 125 ml jars made for a mixed festive board: Christmas Chutney, Spiced Beetroot & Apple Chutney, Northumbrian Red Onion Relish and Pear & Ginger Chutney.

Prefer bigger jars? The Festive Cheeseboard Selection has three 190 ml jars in a festive gift box: Christmas Chutney, our best-selling Northumbrian Chutney with plums and apples, and Spiced Apricot & Orange Chutney.

Just add cheese!

PANTRY STORE